Alejandra Caraballo
Level
City Council
Constituency
District 35
More Information
Campaign Site
2020 LID Questionnaire Response
Why are you running for City Council?
I am a civil rights attorney, advocate, and activist. As part of my professional career I have worked entirely to advance the rights of LGBTQ people. I currently work at TLDEF as a staff attorney and my focus is on bringing national impact litigation to advance transgender rights. Prior to TLDEF, I worked at the New York Legal Assistance Group in the LGBTQ Law Project where I represented LGBTQ immigrants in removal proceedings and affirmative immigration applications for humanitarian relief.
I am running to refocus political power back to the community that has been ignored for so long, particularly on the issues of housing, police reform, and education. As housing committee chair of my community board, I have seen firsthand how our elected leaders have rubber stamped land use and rezoning provisions while ignoring community disapproval. I have also been a witness to the police brutality that lacks all accountability as I was nearly run over by a police cruiser and a family on my block was brutally attacked by NYPD officers during curfew for having a BBQ. Our community has been left without a voice for so long and I will help bring it back to make sure that the City Council actually represents them.
As someone who has represented sex workers, undocumented immigrants, LGBTQ+ people, and intimate partner violence and trafficking survivors, my values have been molded by those experiences of advocating and empowering my clients to have a voice. It has informed my strong internal sense of justice and equity for everyone. I intend to use my campaign and elected position to advocate and empower these communities as they have often been left without a voice. I will fight for justice for marginalized communities.
I ultimately seek to bring the sense of urgency that is required to tackle the monumental crises that face our great city due to COVID. The MTA is insolvent, we face a mass eviction crisis, and our communities face food insecurity like never before. These are artificial disasters waiting to happen and the consequences will be disproportionately born by those who can least afford it. However, these are all solvable issues. Our city has always come back from the crises of the past and I believe that I can help navigate our city through such a perilous time when many of the pessimists have labeled our city “dead.” Simply put, I am running to build a fairer New York for all residents and to get us past an unprecedented crisis by pushing for policies that makes our city stronger than it ever was before.
What are the greatest struggles of your Council district?
Some of the greatest struggles in the district are dealing with the current pandemic. Crown Heights had one of the highest mortality rates for COVID in the country. This has left a crisis of access to food, healthcare, and housing stability. As the pandemic wears on these crises have only gotten worse as food banks struggle to meet demand, healthcare access is being disrupted, and an eviction tsunami looms over the horizon. These are entirely preventable issues that can be fixed through public policy.
In addition, one of the biggest issues is the displacement of long term residents because of gentrification and a lack of housing affordability. Over the past few years, the current city councilwoman has rubber stamped rezonings for sites like the Bedford Armory without giving the community a say in the process. This is occurring again with the 960 Franklin project and other rezonings in the district. These projects lead to massive disruption and displacement of the community. We need leadership that will stand up to developers and instead work to create actual affordable housing.
Why do you want LIDs endorsement? And what does LGBTQ+ representation in the government mean to you?
Despite several LGBQ candidates being in city council and state legislature positions, no openly trans person has ever been elected to a government position. It’s been far too long and we need a seat at the table. The community often talks about uplifting and centering trans women of color and it’s about time we actually do the hard work of giving us a seat at the table. We need a LGBTQ representation that actually has the T part.
What is one thing you would do while in office to make NYC government more inclusive?
I would focus on developing more pipelines to identify young LGBTQ and BIPOC talent that can become the civil service of tomorrow. We can’t just expect diversity to happen and we need to cultivate it through targeted grants and programs for students in high school and college.
What does gender equity mean to you in your district and how can you improve upon it?
This district is majority female with about 54% of the district identifying as female. Despite this, persistent income gaps have caused women to consistently earn less than men. We need to work to ensure that we empower women and do the hard work of ripping out patriarchal structures that ensure inequity for women. These problems are only magnified for gender minorities such the TGNB community. We need to empower the Human Rights Commission to be able to investigate more discrimination broadly to reduce the amount of discrimination for the TGNB communities and women more broadly.
Approximately 40% of runaway and homeless youth are LGBTQ+. The NYC Unity Work Project would have provided training, job placement and development for these communities, but the program ($675k per year) was cut from the city’s budget in FY21. Do you commit to fighting for funding for this or similar programs? How will you support safety and wellness for homeless LGBTQ+ New Yorkers if you are elected?
I commit to funding these vital programs. As a former legal services attorney, I saw first hand how LGBTQ youth were helped by crucial funding for programs such as job trainings, grants to community organizations, and shelters. It’s not a matter of just continuing to fund these programs but to also expand them to provide even more services and protections for LGBTQ youth.
The biggest issue with homeless LGBTQ New Yorkers is that the current shelter system is woefully inadequate. I’ve worked with shelters like Princess Janae Place, Marsha’s House, and Ali Forney Center in the past in various capacities. What I’ve seen across the board is that these organizations do not have the adequate funding or resources to fully support homeless LGBTQ New Yorkers due to their need for intensive programs such as social workers, mental healthcare, crisis counselors, and psychiatric support. The level of trauma our homeless youth suffer is tremendous and many of the orgs are not sufficiently set up to address these issues. Other shelters may offer these services but then the person is at risk of being in an environment that is not LGBTQ friendly. This serves as an incentive for many LGBTQ youth to stay in shelters that don’t provide all of the services that they need.
We also need to revisit the entire shelter system model. We don't just need a right to shelter, we need a right to housing. We need to fundamentally revisit how we approach housing to create a housing first model rather than a shelter only model. This coupled with extensive social support would be far more effective than the shelter model we currently have.
The NYPD’s budget is nearly $6 billion? If elected, will you work to reduce the NYPD’s and invest in non-policing alternatives? By how much?
I am an abolitionist and I have a long term vision of moving away from carceral solutions towards society's problems. I have seen first hand how my clients have suffered at the hands of the criminal justice system. Throughout my legal career, I have had clients profiled by the police for being trans and subsequently harassed and abused by officers. They have been targeted for arrest for simply trying to survive through sex work. We cannot just solve our issues by locking people up. We must work to ensure a day where jails and prisons are no longer needed.
I support actually defunding the NYPD by a minimum of $3 billion, not through budgetary tricks by shifting officers to other agencies. This would be achieved by meaningful cuts in headcount and in military style equipment. We need to fundamentally reimagine what policing looks like in NYC. We need more social workers, legal services, and mental healthcare not more police. The money saved from defunding the NYPD can be used to fund increased direct services by non-profits, social workers, and legal services. The Council's role in this will be to close Rikers and build no new jails. Those billions of dollars can be better spent on building up communities rather than incarcerating them.
In terms of particular agencies that should see increased funding, these would include greater funding for the department of education to provide more social workers and mental healthcare professionals instead of school resource officers. There need to be increased funding for the FDNY so that they are better equipped with mental health crisis units that can respond to individuals in crisis rather than police. Greater funding for the HHC to provide more direct mental healthcare through the NYC Cares program for the uninsured and more broadly for those with issues getting access to mental healthcare.
What is your plan to help the city financially recover from the economic crisis caused by COVID19? What will your priorities be if there is a second wave of COVID19?
The honest answer is that the city is not a metaphorical island that can recover on its own. We will need substantial help from the federal government if we are to recover to pre-COVID times. I would work extensively with our federal delegation and Biden administration officials to prioritize building our city back in an equitable manner that emphasizes uplifting those most impacted by the effects of COVID.
The second wave is already here. We need to ensure that the eviction moratorium is actually implemented so that no one loses housing in the middle of a pandemic. We need to ensure that our public hospitals have the supplies and staff necessary to deal with a second surge of COVID patients. As a member of the Kings County Hospital Community Advisory Board, I have been keeping up to date to make sure that our public hospitals can handle a second wave. Finally, we need to address the hunger crisis in our city. Since SNAP does not apply to so many households, in particular immigrants, there is a food security crisis that is currently happening. We need to increase funding directly to mutual aid groups that know their communities and are in the best position to distribute food.
What if any initiatives do you propose to help with the climate crisis?
I support the renewable Rikers project. The closure of Rikers as a city jail is a unique opportunity to turn city owned land into a hub of green renewable energy such as solar, tidal, and wind energy. This will allow the city to move carbon intensive power generation away from traditionally lower income neighborhoods and focus on clean renewable energy.
What will you do to support labor unions if elected? Did you publicly support the Association of Legislative Employees (the union that represents council staffers) in their request for voluntary recognition?
As a former member of the organizing committee and bargaining committee of UAW Local 2325 at NYLAG, I know firsthand how important it is to have a union and collective bargaining. I publicly supported the voluntary recognition of the City Council union.
In the context of public unions, I would explicitly encourage organization and recruitment efforts by unions to allow unions access to new hires and employees and sharing information about public employees with union leadership. Create an opt out default where fees are collected by default but those wishing not to pay have to opt out rather than an opt in system.
Finally, we need to create grants for union organizers so that they have the support they need to organize workers into unions.
How much money has your campaign raised and what are your major sources
I have raised $10,696.59 with 123 donors which is about $60,000 in matching funds. I have nearly 30 in district donors and the vast majority of donors are from NYC. I am on track to meet the in district donor requirement of 75 by the January filing.
Are you accepting campaign contributions from law enforcement sources? Real Estate Sources?
Absolutely not. I have pledged to not take money from law enforcement unions or developers.
Do you commit to using inclusive and gender neutral language in press releases and other announcements (e.g., “the people of the…” instead of “the men and women of the…”)?
Yes, as a transgender woman, I understand the importance of respecting everyone’s pronouns and making sure we eliminate unnecessary gendered language.
Yes or no, do you support the following city council initiatives:
Intro 2047: Prevents landlords from discriminating against criminal legal system involved tenants: Yes
Intro 2050: Allows noncitizens to vote in municipal elections: Yes
Reso 0923: Calls for the state to repeal Penal Law 240.37, known as the #WalkingWhileTrans Ban: Yes
Intro 1314/Fair Chance Act 2.0: Prohibits discriminatoin based on one’s arrest record, pending criminal accusations, or criminal convictions. Prevents employers from inquiring about #WalkingWhileTrans Ban arrests: Yes
Intro 2012: Requires NYPD to report on custodial interrogations of minors: Yes
Intro 1529: Expands access to an attorney for tenants in eviction proceedings: Yes
DNA protection bill introduced by CM Richardson and CM Ayala: Prevents NYPD from collecting samples of DNA from children without consent form a parent or guardian: Yes